If you can't cast it this way, or it's a land, you put that card into your hand
You do need to attack with him which is dicey but the payoff is stronger: essentially everyone should make the person with the most cards draw and the person who is empty-handed put a permanent into play, but you can at least vote for yourself when you want to draw (or everyone votes for themselves to draw)
But many times, youll probably have a centaur or better on the table when you get around to playing this, so youll actually be getting a 3/3 ground token and a 1/1 flyer
If Communal Brewing leaves the battlefield before its last ability resolves, use the number of ingredient counters that were on it as it last existed on the battlefield to determine the value of X
However, if one player casts Dragon Fodder and the other plays Shivan Dragon, who do you think came out on top
Lets hop right in and see what makes it so different